- Search for Research Summaries, Reviews, and Reports
- EPC Project
Related Products for this Topic
Related Links for this Topic
Consumer Summary – Oct. 29, 2010
Treatment Options for Rotator Cuff Tears: A Guide for Adults
Table of Contents
- Is This Guide for Me?
- Understanding Your Condition
- Understanding Your Treatment Options
- Making a Decision
Is This Guide for Me?
- YES, if your doctor has told you that you have a rotator cuff tear, which is an injury to one or more of the muscles and tendons in your shoulder.
- NO, if you have any other type of shoulder or upper back injury, or an injury that is not related to the rotator cuff. Talk to your doctor to learn if this guide is right for you.
This guide will tell you about what research has found regarding the different choices for treating your rotator cuff tear. You can use it to help you and your doctor or other health care provider (nurse practitioner, physician’s assistant, physical therapist) discuss and decide what treatments are best for you.
Where does the information for this guide come from?
The information in this guide comes from a review of the many different studies on treatments for rotator cuff tears. It is not based on a single study but on many studies looked at together by a team of researchers, doctors, and other experts.
Understanding Your Condition
What is a rotator cuff?
Your rotator cuff is a group of four muscles on your shoulder blade with tendons that attach to the “ball” of your humerus (upper arm bone).
These muscles and tendons help you to lift and rotate your arms. They also help hold the ball of your humerus firmly in your shoulder socket.
What is a rotator cuff tear?
The tendons of your rotator cuff can tear much like a piece of leather. Sometimes, the tendon is only slightly damaged or irritated. Sometimes, the tendon has a complete tear, which means that the tendon has torn away from the bone.
What causes rotator cuff tears?
The tendons of your rotator cuff can tear for a variety of reasons:
- An injury, such as falling or being hit in the shoulder.
- Overuse over time from repeated actions, such as lifting, painting, cleaning windows, or throwing.
- Natural wear and tear from aging.
How rotator cuff tears affect your life
Tears in your rotator cuff are not life-threatening, but they can limit movement and cause pain.
Even small shoulder and arm movements, like combing your hair, putting on a coat, or lifting groceries, may be difficult and can hurt.
The pain can range from mild, to moderate, to sharp. You may feel pain on top of and in front of your injured shoulder. The pain may spread down the outside of your upper arm. You may feel more pain at night, especially when you are lying on the injured shoulder.
Swelling from inflammation is your body’s natural response to injury. Sometimes this swelling is inside of your body and you cannot see it. This swelling is the most common cause of your pain.
Cracking and stiffness
You may hear clicking, cracking, or popping sounds when you move your shoulder, especially when lifting something heavy.
Understanding Your Treatment Options
Two types of treatments
There are two types of treatments for your rotator cuff tear. Patients get better with both of these kinds of treatments.
- Non-surgical treatments (see below). This includes physical therapy and other treatments. These treatments are often used first, before considering surgery.
- Surgical treatments (see "Three types of surgery" below). There are different kinds of surgery used. All surgery comes with specific risks.
Your doctor or health care provider may advise you to have one or both of these types of treatments for your rotator cuff tear. This advice will depend on the type and size of your injury.
The amount of damage to the tendon of your rotator cuff will help your doctors decide what treatments you may need and how long treatment may take.
Treating your rotator cuff tear without surgery
Rotator cuff tears are treated without surgery in these ways:
- Undergoing physical or occupational therapy. A skilled therapist assists you with a variety of exercises and stretches to strengthen your shoulder muscles.
- Taking oral medicines. These medicines may include either acetaminophen or “nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs” (also called “NSAIDs”), such as ibuprofen or naproxen.
- Taking a steroid as a pill or an injection.
Which treatment should I choose?
Many of these non-surgical treatments have been shown to help improve pain, weakness, and arm movement. However, there is not much information about which treatment type is better than the other.
Your doctor or health care provider may use several of these treatments at the same time to help you.
There is also not enough research to know how these treatments compare with surgery in improving the use of your rotator cuff.
Your role in treatment
You play an important role in your recovery. Be sure to follow the instructions from your doctor or other health care provider, keep your therapy appointments, and do your home exercises. Talk to your doctor about what to expect during treatment and when you should start feeling better.
Repairing your rotator cuff tear with surgery
How long do I wait before choosing surgery?
There is not enough information from studies to answer this question. Your doctor or health care provider may explore your options with you based on the type and size of your tear and how long you have had the injury. Physical therapy may be enough to help improve the pain and weakness, or surgery may be a better treatment choice. In some cases, surgery is used when physical therapy does not improve symptoms.
How is the rotator cuff repaired during surgery?
In most cases, a surgeon uses stitches to connect the torn edges of the muscle or tendon back together or to connect the tendon back to the ball of your humerus. This is called “rotator cuff repair.”
In addition, your doctor may consider two other surgical treatments:
- Removing loose fragments of tendon or damaged bone or cartilage that may be lodged in the joint. This is called “debridement” (pronounced dee-BREED-ment).
- Removing some of the bone underneath the shoulder blade, or some of the tissue between the bones (called “ligaments”) in your shoulder joint to give the tendon more room to move your arm freely. This is called “acromioplasty” (pronounced ah-KROM-ee-o-plast-ee).
- Arthroscopic surgery: The surgeon makes very small openings (cuts) into the muscles of your shoulder and uses a device called an “arthroscope” (a small tube attached to a camera and tiny surgical instruments) to repair the tear.
- Open surgery: The surgeon makes a larger opening into the muscles of your shoulder and repairs the tear with regular surgical instruments.
- Mini-open surgery: The surgeon uses an arthroscope for the first part of the surgery, and then makes an opening large enough to use other surgical instruments for the repair. The opening does not have to be as big or affect the muscle as much as with open surgery.
What type of surgery should I choose?
Research found that:
- There is no difference between the open, mini-open, and arthroscopic types of surgery in the improvement of shoulder function. They all work about the same. However, arthroscopic surgery usually requires less recovery time.
- A few studies found that:
- Some patients who had mini-open surgery returned to work or sports about 1 month sooner than those who had open surgery.
- Some patients who had open repair surgery had better improvement of their shoulder function than those who had arthroscopic debridement (removing loose tendon, bone, or cartilage fragments that are lodged in the joint) without repair of the tear.
- The results for the patients who had arthroscopic surgery with or without acromioplasty (creating more space in the joint by removing some bone or tissue) were about the same.
Is surgery safe?
All surgeries come with some risk. You and your doctor can decide what risks may exist for you based on your overall health. Rotator cuff surgery is safe for most people. The most common problems are infection and re-tears.
What type of treatment should I have after my surgery?
Although most doctors agree that you should have rehabilitation therapy after your surgery, there is not enough evidence to tell you which type is best. Talk to your doctor or health care provider about what kind of rehabilitation therapy is best for you.
Making a Decision
Ask your doctor
- Given my tear, what benefits and harms for using non-surgical or surgical treatments should I consider?
- If I need surgery, given my tear and my other medical conditions, which surgery (open, mini-open, or arthroscopic) do you think would be best for me?
- What type of treatment will I need after surgery?
- How long do you think it will take me after treatment to return to my activities?
- Will these treatments help my rotator cuff for many years?
- When should I expect my pain and other symptoms to feel better?
The information in this guide comes from the report Comparative Effectiveness of Nonoperative and Operative Treatments for Rotator Cuff Tears. It was produced by the University of Alberta Evidence-based Practice Center through funding by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ). For a copy of the report, or for more information about AHRQ and the Effective Health Care Program, go to www.effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov. Additional information came from the Medline-Plus® Web site, a service of the U.S. National Library of Medicine and the National Institutes of Health. This site is available at www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/.
This summary was prepared by the John M. Eisenberg Center for Clinical Decisions and Communications Science at Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX. It was written by Andrea Humphries, Ph.D., Thomas Workman, Ph.D., Chantele Singleton M.S., CHES, Laura Petersen, M.D., Charles Reitman, M.D., and Michael Fordis, M.D. Illustrations were created by Douglas Alexander. Patients with rotator cuff injury reviewed this summary.